By Kathy Acosta, LCSW, Founder of HERO Counseling Center
By the time someone reaches out to me about EMDR, they’ve usually already done a fair amount of research. They know it’s a science- based approach for processing traumatic memories, and they’ve probably read that it doesn’t require talking through every detail of what happened the way traditional talk therapy does. What they usually haven’t figured out yet is how to tell one EMDR therapist from another, or what questions actually matter when they’re choosing someone to do this work with.
I get it. Trusting someone with the hardest parts of your history is not a decision to make based on a directory listing and a nice headshot.
Here’s what I’d actually ask, both as a therapist who does this work and as someone who has sat on the other side of that search myself.
Ask whether they are EMDR-trained or EMDRIA-certified
Many people do not realize that being trained in EMDR is different from being certified by EMDRIA. Standard EMDR training typically includes 40 hours of instruction across two training weekends, along with 10 hours of follow-up group consultation.
EMDRIA certification requires additional clinical experience, consultation, and continuing education beyond the initial training. A therapist can be properly trained and experienced in EMDR without being certified, but you deserve to understand their level of preparation.
It is completely fair to ask directly: “Are you EMDR-trained or EMDRIA-certified, and how long have you been using EMDR with clients?”
Ask whether they specialize in what you’re bringing in
EMDR was initially developed for single-incident trauma, but over the years, it has evolved to treat much more. Today, it is also used for complex trauma, childhood trauma, domestic violence, racial trauma, generational patterns, phobias, fears, and anxiety. I specialize in EMDR for intergenerational trauma and for BIPOC clients specifically, because the way trauma shows up in someone who grew up code-switching between cultures, or absorbing a parent’s unspoken pain, is not the same as a single event. A therapist who is honest about their specific experience, rather than presenting EMDR as one-size-fits-all, is usually the safer bet.
I remember a client who had already tried EMDR once before, with someone who treated her family history as a single background detail rather than something actively shaping her symptoms. It didn’t go anywhere. When we started over and built the timeline around three generations of women in her family, not just her own most recent memory, the work finally moved.
Ask the practical questions early
Cost and insurance shouldn’t feel like an awkward afterthought. Ask what a session costs, whether the therapist is in-network with your insurance, and whether they offer EMDR Intensives, longer, concentrated sessions over consecutive days that some people prefer to weekly sessions stretched out over months. Ask how many sessions they typically expect for something like yours, understanding that any honest therapist will say it depends.
Ask how they’ll handle it if it gets hard
EMDR can bring up more than people expect in a single session. I’ve had clients ask me, sometimes nervously, what happens if they need to stop mid-processing. The honest answer: you’re always in control, and a well-trained EMDR therapist will spend real time on grounding and stabilization skills before ever asking you to process a difficult memory, not just jump straight to it because it’s the technique they’re known for.
Choosing a therapist is not the same as choosing anyone else you hire. It’s someone who’s going to be present with you in some genuinely hard moments. Asking a few pointed questions up front is not overkill — it’s exactly what a trauma-informed therapist would want you to do, and they usually have questions for you too.
Kathy Acosta, LCSW, is the founder of HERO Counseling Center, an EMDR-certified therapist specializing in EMDR intensives for intergenerational trauma and BIPOC clients. For more information visit: http://herocenternj.com/emdr




